Fan Question
- V
my almost 3 year old has the worse attitude ever.
always telling people to shut up throwing things when mad or when she is told no.demands you to give her things will have an angry face and tell you to get it or give something up. If i tell her to pick up a mess she made she will scream grunt and stomp away iâll make her come back and clean it up.
But my husband thinks she is ODD (Oppositional defiant disorder) which to me sounds like an excuse to not listen to me. the way i feel is she is the child and will listen to me i am the adult you do not tell me no you not tell me to shut up or have such a nasty attitude. Iâve tried time out spanking and talking it out nothings works.
We also have a new baby so i know she is acting out because of that and i do include her in things with him changing diapers bath playing etc i also make time for her daily walks the park bed time stories. i just dont know what to do about this attitude. ALL THE TIME she is like this.
iâm losing my mind she got like this maybe 2 months before the baby was born She use to say please and thank you ask permission for things or to do something and was happy all the time. any advice
19 Likes
It could be because of the baby, but it sounds like ODD is also a possibility if itâs all the time. Might be a good idea to get a behavioral counselor involved.
3 Likes
Have her vision checked. My child had major attitude and anger issues. She calmed down a lot once we realized she was frustrated because she couldnât see!! Iâm not saying that is what is going on with yours, but I didnât connect vision and behavior either.
Also donât give in to her tantrums!!!
2 Likes
Sounds like she may be jeoulous of new baby.Stay strong she will get better as long as you keep up the discipline and be consistant.
2 Likes
Idk if automatically assuming she has a disorder is the right route. Who is she seeing thatâs being nasty and telling people to shut up or being demanding? Kids donât just know âshut upâ. Find the source of where sheâs getting the behavior from and minimize it. not saying that its you, but take a look at yourself as well. Are you telling her please and thank you? Are you telling her to shut up? I have found that I have expectations of my toddler that I donât follow myself at times.
10 Likes
Sheâs a kid! Donât go throwing labels of mental disorders around, probably just jealousy over the baby or something is majorly upsetting her. Sheâs three, all kids between 2 and 3 years old push boundaries and fight back. Spanking can make matters worse, they become more angry and less likely to listen to you because youâve hurt them, or they go the other way because you scare the shit out of them!
Discipline her with the naughty step, loss of sweets/treats and temporarily rake away the things she leaves a mess with. Or failing that a chart system where she gets a small treat at the end of the week.
Also she may be learning these behaviours from elsewhere, found out if she is and try to minimize it.
Bare but spank. Only thing that worked on my kids.
5 Likes
Starts with the parenting đ€·
4 Likes
slapped backside is called for.
6 Likes
Poor behavior remedy is isolate and ignore. No arguing. No eye contact. Totally ignore her right where she is, no corner etc. Once you are no longer her captive audience, her star of the show is removed. I did daycare for 10 years. This works, just keep doing it, she will learn. No please , no thank you, again ignore when no manners are used. Good luck.
11 Likes
We do lead by example. And something is bothering her, and she does not know how to Express it healthy, it being a medical problem or a jealously problem.
1 Like
Try a good behavior sticker chart and see if it works also maybe a talk to pediatrician about your husbands concerns to rule out any possibility of a disability.
Yes include her⊠Let her help you ⊠make it into a lil game⊠I do this with my youngest oneâŠ
I think I would honestly ignore her. Donât give in to anything, not react. Walk into the other room and shut the door. Address her again when sheâs calm. Idk. Iâve never had a problem like that with any of my kids.
1 Like
I think she needs more attention, I think you need to put your anger aside for a moment to find out why sheâs doing what sheâs doing. I feel like sheâll take the negative attention because attention is all she wants. Have a mom to daughter heart to 
. Thatâs your baby and you will have plenty more to come.
Good luck. Mine is 5 and is just now growing out of that phase. I just ignored her
1 Like
Whoop her ass. Children these days need their ass whooped.
My son has never acted like this⊠Itâs
Called discipline you spank there butt, you ground them you take stuff away⊠On the plus side let her help make it seam fun to be a big sister⊠And when baby is sleeping spend some one on one time
1 Like
My 4 year old does this⊠So following.
Your a great mother sorry you are struggling at the moment, you will figure this out breathe⊠Just thought you might need to hear your doing a great job Mom!
1 Like
She is testing her boundaries which is normal at this age, however, you need to discipline her for bad behavior (spank her butt, pop her in the mouth when she back talks or screams at you/other people) and you need to ignore her commands. If you donât nip this in the bud now it will only get worse the older she gets.
4 Likes
Bust some butt.not beat,just an attitude adjustment.
3 Likes
One of my 4 year olds was this way to I was at a lose so I talked to a child therapist and was told if they are not endangering themselves or someone else donât respond. I did this there were days that were so bad I wanted to give up but it took about 2 months of ignoring his fits and it stopped. Donât get me wrong he still has a fit every now in then every child does but itâs so much better
1 Like
You are describing my three year old. We also have a one year old. I think this is totally normally. What works for us: Outings with just me and her, hugs and breathing techniques when she gets really upset, being firm with her when she gets to the point of being physical, timeout when necessary, rewarding good behavior on occasion (not every time), talking to her about her day as a part of bedtime routine, discussing our loved ones (its nice for her to verbally say that she loves her little brother- I think it reinforces the idea to treat him nicely), long walks/exercise every evening to get out excess energy, limited screen time.
1 Like
My son was the same. Diagnosed with odd and adhd. Still whines and we butt heads but itâs a lot better.
2 Likes
They mimic what they seeâŠjust saying
5 Likes
I agree w some of the moms w the ignoring her when she misbehavesâŠIâm not saying if she does something terribly wrong that it shouldnât be addressed but she could be just looking for a reactionâŠwhether its outta jealousy or just cuz she is in the terrible 2s phase (ik she is almost 3 but sometimes the phase can come early or late). But nevertheless, try ignoring her and let her get whatever it is out. Once she sees youâre not even entertaining her behavior, then she may realize she is gonna get more sugar by being the sweet little girl she once was. Best of luck to ya, mamaâ€
1 Like
She is only 3!!! Not 16. Folks, you can not reason with a 3 year old. At 3, her brain is not fully developed to understand your expectations. Be patient and understanding and loving instead of punishments.
4 Likes
My oldest was like that and she is ADHD/ODD and strong willed
1 Like
Start whooping that ass. Problem will be solved very fastâŠ
Iâd take away all of her things she likes to do when she acts like that leave her with nothing to do no toys or I pads or tv make her sit there and think about her actions for a day or 2
1 Like
Oh my gosh this sounds exactly like my 3 year old right now. Iâm a couple months away from having our 3rd baby. My 3 year old is the oldest. So she knows whatâs coming and I think itâs giving her anxiety and making her act out. Iâm glad you posted because now I know itâs not just my 3 year old acting like satans spawn. But the only advice I can give is to stay consistent. Whatever discipline you are doing just keep doing it and donât cave. Sooner or later Iâm hoping they realize they donât get their way and will lose the attitude⊠at least until the teenage years 
If it is ODD or some other behavioral health issue, I think you should seek information or a counselor who can help coach you through. It sounds exhausting Mama, just remember youâre doing your best, donât give up. 
Talk to her doctor. In some cases, it really in a behavior issue and not an âattitude problem.â I donât power struggle and kick in to âIâm the boss and you listen to meâ attitudes with my kids. 3 is rough. Theyâre learning so much and donât have a handle on feelings and emotions. Adding a new sibling to that confusion probably means sheâll take attention any way she can get it. But ignoring her will probably end up being g counter-productive. Maybe talk to her and explain her feelings and appropriate actions thoroughly instead of feeling like you have to jump straight to punishment.
Make sure your child isnât being abused sexually especially if her attitude changed very quick. I hope I am wrong. Does she know about good touch bad touch. I was abused as a child and kept it to myself for years. I hope no one hurt her. For behavior You tell her 1 means Stop if you say 2 that is a warning if you say three there is a consequence so she goes in time out for three minutes because she is three. Set a timer. Tell her you love her afterwards but that behavior will not be tolerated. If you still have trouble start taking her toys away one at a time and when she is good she gets a toy back. Good luck. You can also do a chart where she earns stickers for helping mommy around the house. Make a treasure box she can pick one thing from when she has earned so many stickers or candy if you choose that. Just one sucker or dollar tree toys.
My daughter was the same way, she was my 3rd child and I had never had a problem with my other 2. I tried everything until she got to school and started having to be picked up almost everyday. She was diagnosed at 6 with ODD and ADHD, she is 8 now and sheâs a lot better. Good luck mamađ
ODD wouldnât be diagnosed til around 7 years old . Punish her . Around this age all children test boundaries , discipline and ignore the bad behavior when she is yelling and screaming or try some one on one attention she may be acting out for attention , maybe help her when cleaning up
I thimk i would ask the doctor.
When she acts up completely ignore her. Do not look at her when sheâs throwing a fit, do not answer any questions⊠Ignore her completely⊠Until she calms down and acts right. At first obviously you have to say something like, âI canât understand you when you are yelling. And im not doing anything for you until you start being nice.â But other than that, ignore her. Show her that her bad attitude wonât get her any attention.
And when sheâs acting right make it a point to say things like, âThank you for asking so kindly.â And, âlook at my big girl!â Show her that when she acts right, she will get attention.
I know it sounds far fetched but thatâs the only thing that worked for me with my kids.
4 Likes
This is very normal for a 3 yr old. There are hard wired to test ur EVERY boundaries!!! And its actually good for them in the long run developmentally. Yes, this is a very difficult time. Im going thro the same thing. It makes u wonder why u starting thinking it was such a good idea to have kids in the 1st place. But its makes the person who they are BECOMING. And yes some days us moms have days where we handle it better than others, but the love we show them⊠is what they are gonna remember!!! So be patient. And what helps me is trying to think of things as if IM HIM/HER!!! everything seems urgent and over the top. When u show them that it CAN BE A SIMPLE FIX. As far as a form of punishment⊠each child and parent is different. So you need to find something that ur child will be uncomfortable with and that YOU AS A MOTHER ARE!!! IT DOESNT MATTER OTHERS SAY!!! THAT CHILD IS YOURS!!! U DONT NEED PERMISSION FROM ANYONE
I swear my kids had the terrible 3âs not 2âs. Iâm sure its a combination of that and the new baby. Stay strong and be consistant.
You can not reason with a 3 yr old. Spanking ( not beating) will teach her that such behavior will result in consequences that she will not enjoy. Be consistent and tell her why she is being punished.
2 Likes
Sheâs 3 and experiencing massive changes. You canât reason with a toddler. Theyâre explosive because they donât understand their feelings .be patient.
We got spanked when we acted like that. No harm in spanking.
3 Likes
I do childcare and see this kind of thing a lot. Always been well behaved and then like a light switchâŠboom⊠attitudeâŠthreenager! However, since it was so sudden, I would first make sure that there isnât another reason for it. Did something traumatic happen? Is there another problem. I would speak to her Dr about it and rule those things out. After thatâŠkeep on with what youâre doing. Keep trying new forms of discipline until you find the thing that gets her attention⊠taking things away, early bedtime, no treats, ectâŠ
My daughter is almost 4 & we have the same situation. The new baby is a month old & while she loves him, her attitude when she doesnât want to do something is extremely challenging. We put her in her room & ignore her because spanking is useless & she hits so I donât want to encourage it. The lack of attention during that time (sheâs very social) & having to stay in one spot, seems to be the best âdisciplineâ. We are also looking at doing a stoplight behavior chart.
My nephew was this way. He was 2 and mean and angry and would smack you in the face. He was staying with my mom at the time and she said she was about to give up on him. Then one morning for whatever reason in stead of fussing at him, she grabbed him and hugged him and kissed him. Everytime he would lash out she would hug him tight and love on him. He stopped fighting and lashing out. He is the sweetest child now at 9 years old. He loves hugs and kisses. Sometimes children just need the extra assurance.
3 Likes
From personal experience, I explained to my children how their behavior made me feel and in turn started treating them the way they were treating us and it helped. Now the only issue we have is a bit of sibling rivalry but the tantrums and hatred were lessened
1 Like
Where did she pick it up from?
Everyone will probably tell you its a phase ( which may be true) I never had to deal with stuff like that from my kids. Just make sure you set your rules/boundaries & you stick to it. No letting some things fly sometimes & not others. Make sure the punishments are the same too. She needs to learn that nothing good comes from acting that way toward others.
Put her in time out. If she gets up put her back. 2 min per age. But the time donât startâŠuntil she is sitting in time out. Do not speak to her after place ing her there. Others then You do not like her bad behavior. And because she has broken the house rules⊠She now need to sit in time out. Even if you have to replace her there a million times⊠which at first. You just might have tooâŠAfter a few times she should get the understanding. But after sitting in time outâŠwhich can not be the childâs bedroom ⊠& after their time is upâŠAsk the child if they know why they needed to sit there . Then give them a hug & tell them you love them. But you will not tolerate that type of bad behavior either. Stick to ur rules. It might be hard. I mean really hard. & you might feel like crying âŠBut ur momâŠStay strong.
Sheâs no longer in her terrible 2s this is get terrorist 3s lol. Try ignoring her until she acts right and praise her for good behavior. Plus Kids can sense when there is a new baby and I have yet to meet a young sibling that didnât act out at least a little bit with new siblings. She does not have ODD this early. She is just testing your boundaries. Set them and stay firm. Find your proper form of punishment and use that every kid is different
All kids go through a phase were their complete assholes 
just breathe, take it one day at a time and realize their just a kid, they dont yet know how to control their emotions. If you lose your cool, thatâs what their going to learn.
What is she hearing at home?
Tear her butt up. She will change that attitude within 5 mins of a spanking. She needs boundaries and it doesnt sound like you have set any.
2 Likes
She is 3 and they are walking attitudes with anger issues so yes you have to prove that you are the boss and just stay firm when the bad behaviour starts but also keep up with the love and her time when she is not angry at the world. And yes if she is throwing things and hitting people a quick sweat to that butt can be a good attention getter.
1 Like
You have a three-nager and its not easy but find what will get to her. With my daughter I tried everything then out of desperation I tried making her put her nose in the corner for one minute for every year of life. Three minutes with her nose in the corner really went all over her cause she couldnât see what was going on in the room. Be consistent if nothing else! The same repercussions for the same infraction no matter your mood, make a list while you are calm and relaxed. I had PMS so bad that I would let her get away with things when I was PMSing really bad cause I feared I would be harder on her cause of my bad mood. Making a list of general things kids do and what the consequence it earns them made my life soooo much easier. I have a very well adjusted, happy and wonderful adult daughter now. She is a joy to have. Even if your daughter has a mood/behavior issue you still have to work hard to help her become a good citizen for her own benefit in life.<3 Just know, itâs always something you seem to go from issue to issue with children, just see it as a goal set and work hard to finish and then on to the next. Good Luck mamma
Who is she around thats influencing her
My one daughter is the same way and she will be 3 in SeptemberâŠignore the bad behavior and it will get boring to herâŠI have been doing this and itâs slowly fading awayâŠespecially with a new baby she is doing whatever she can and knows if she acts badly she will get attention
She heard shut up somewhere⊠if my granddaughter refused to pick up, I didnât get mad or raise my voice, but told her if I picked them up, theyâd get put away for the rest of the day or for the whole next day⊠one time is all it took! No threats, no other punishment(just her knowing she couldnât/ wouldnât have them to play with, was enough)!! I canât stress to you the importance of your behavior. Calm, no yelling. Important for you to be calm when theyâre coming unraveled
Yeah think itâs her age compainioned by the new baby sheâs adjusting to having to share you
Even if she has ODD she needs to listen. Itâs much better to catch them when they are young and to stay focused and maintain the discipline. Whether or not they have ODD or not. She could just be your run of the mill 3 year old jerk with jealousy issues because there is a new baby in the picture. Whatever happens just be open to it if the teachers have problems with her in kindergarten. Stay strong.
Imagine. A kid hitting you in anger, after being hit in anger for punishment.
1 Like
Iâm concerned with the âshe is the child and will listen to me, Iâm the adult you donât tell me noâ⊠itâs not about trying to control your child. Itâs about teaching her to control herself. You shouldnât strive for turning her into an obedient little robot, but rather an independent, and resilient adult.
Punishments like spanking has not only been proven to be psychologically damaging, but that and other forms of punishment like time outs might get her to behave in the short term, but only because sheâs afraid. Your goal should be that she does the right thing because she actually wants to and it makes her feel good.
This is where lots of praise should come in. Acknowledge the good things she does âI see you put your shoes away, youâre being so helpful thank you, etcâ there should be way more praise than nagging. When she starts throwing things, deflect the situation by saying âwe canât throw things inside because we might break something, letâs go outside and throw a ballâ or âI see youâre upset. I canât let you throw things, did you want a hug, or scream into this pillow? Letâs get that anger out so we can go back to playingâ she wonât pick up her toys âletâs play a game and see how fast we can pick up these toysâ. Make things fun for her, hug her when sheâs upset and let her know you still love her even though sheâs doing things you donât want her to. Give her lots of choices so that she feels she has a say, even for something as simple as âdid you want a banana or an apple for a snack?â, âyou need to come clean your mess. Did you want to hop like a bunny back here, or pretend youâre a bird? Mommy will pretend with you tooâ. As for the attitude, sheâs learning those words from somewhere. Iâm not implying you are saying it, but if you donât like certain words then correct it every single time âtry another word please. It hurts mommy when you say those thingsâ
It seems you are understanding the underlying issues that may be there, like the fact that there is a new baby, and that you need to make time for her, but I donât think you have enough empathy for what her developing mind is going through. You need to change your mindset. Sheâs not plotting against you, sheâs just acting on impulse. Her brain is still developing and there are a lot of things that are easy for us to comprehend, but keep in mind, the brain doesnât stop developing until the age of 25 so your daughter still has a long way to go before she gets to your level of understanding.
Be patient mama. Remember that this is just a phase.
You have to be consistent, donât let them rule you, you rule them, and you are the grown up and the parents
People often forget, kids have adult sized emotions. When she is being defiant ask her how she is feeling, offer up a few words mad, sad, angry, disappointed, lonely, frustrated. Give her the choice of words then teach her how to deal with them appropriately, and let her know that bad behaviour is not on. Also recognise her signs, so before she starts throwing things so you can diffuse the bomb before it explodes. âOk honey, please clean up those toys or we wonât be going to the parkâ give her instructions with consequences. If you need to help her or need to ask more than 3 times, she doesnât get the park.
Children aged three on average only listen 40% of the time!!!